History is all about people.
So it’s unfortunate that
historians are hampered by word count, yet have the necessity of
imparting as many facts as possible about events which occurred at certain
periods in certain places, for, as far as they know, whatever reasons, into school history books. Which does tend to make the books rather
dull, and difficult for a teacher to arouse any enthusiasm in the students.
What reader is interested in, or inspired by, dry, boring
facts? In Scotland of the nineteen fifties,
for the final nation-wide exams on history at a certain level, knowledge of
ancient history was essential. The student was expected to know the dates of
famous battles such as Thermopylae, and the Punic wars, and what caused them, the Spartans and the
Carthaginians, and so on. As my mother
patiently tested me I droned the answers as a fourth grader would the
multiplication tables. At length Mother
threw down the book in exasperation.
“What did the ordinary Spartans, or any of these people,
look like? Were their families looked
after while the men were away? You know
nothing about the ordinary lives of these people, yet you have to learn the
dates of all these wars and battles. What do you know about the Great War?
(that was the first world war,1914-19)
My uncles fought in that, and so did some of your Daddy’s brothers. These were men I knew. What do you know about them? Blind Hughie, the pedlar, you mind
(remember) him? That was shrapnel did
that at Mons. Can you tell me the date of that battle? Passchendaele? That’s history. History is all about people, ordinary
people. They count.”
I reflected my own
grandchildren know next to nothing about the Second World War, and its
devastating effects on peoples’ lives in town and country in the land of my
birth. Good, decent people, whose
stories deserve to be told. This
prompted Alec’s War, a story about the effects of WWll on a schoolboy and his
family after the attack on Clydebank in March, 1941. The Blitz hammered mainly London and the major
English industrial cities; in quiet Clydebank, next sizeable town to Scotland’s
largest city of Glasgow, they still spoke of the phony war. Until the Germans decided to attack John
Brown’s Shipyards on the River Clyde.
War stories after 1946 claimed that Hitler issued orders to
bomb civilians in order to break the British spirit and demoralise the
troops. It had the opposite effect.
Modern historians are charitable regarding the bombing of Clydebank. The Forth and Clyde Canal runs parallel to
the River Clyde at Clydebank; they
suggest the Germans mistook the canal for the river, thus the civilians, not
the ships on the Clyde or in John Brown’s yards, took the brunt of the attack. Not a shop window in the town was left
intact, and seventy per cent of the dwellings were destroyed. The spirit of the people was not; in the
midst of the mourning and grim determination to carry on, they exhibited wry,
sometimes gallows, humour. I glimpsed a fraction of what they had to
endure when I first visited Clydebank to stay with my high school friend. Though it was well into the fifties, there were still many pock-marked buildings
and vacant sites where craters made by bombs had been filled in but were still
undeveloped, left overgrown and forlorn.
Rendered homeless, Alec and his siblings were evacuated to
live with his aunt in the country. They
had often stayed for summer holidays with her in the rural village where she
taught. This time, he found life there
was not going to be as quiet as on previously visits. The tentacles of war
snarled lives just as much, if in different ways from the cities. There was the Black Market, the Fifth
Columnists who undermined the government’s war effort, and sundry spies. Alec, a keen Sherlock Holmes fan, finds a
mission of his own. Young children of
those days were as enterprising and innovative as children have always
been. They also had considerably more
responsibility than we allow our modern children to enjoy.
Mother was right – history is all about people; ordinary
people doing extraordinary things.
A very good definition of what history is. It's HIStory and HERstory.
ReplyDelete